Emerging Indo-Pakistan equations
-DR. ABDUL RUFF COLACHAL
_______________
Decomposed in real terms owing mainly to mutual suspicion, hatred and resultant tensions, Indo-Pakistani relations have been in a low key since these two nations came into existence in 1947 for various reasons, both real and fictitious, including the Kashmir cum nuke flashpoint. .
World is watching very carefully how the newly emerged Modi regime would handle the usual Hindutva and other confrontational issues – both domestic and foreign- that made the party popular among Hindus.
With the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) forming a majority government in India under the leadership of Narendra Modi, questions are being raised about the implications for Kashmir and India–Pakistan relations.
Many Kashmiri leaders have expressed hope that the BJP, once in power, may take the process forward from where Vajpayee left off and that Modi may prove to be another Vajpayee.But Modi is no Vajpayee to give an altogether new direction to the conflict resolution process and carry the nation along with him.
Narendra Modi, who rose dramatically from a boy who was selling tea at a railway station in Gujarat to premier of India of over a billion people by serving the cause of Hindutva in practice, started his day of his new duties as Indian PM by assuming charge at the Prime Minister’s Office, known is short as the PMO.
Narendra Modi was administered oath of office and secrecy by President Pranab Mukherjee as India’s 15th Prime Minister along with his 44-member Cabinet on May 26th evening.
The invitation for the swearing in ceremony sent by Indian premier elect Narandra Modi to the SAARC leaders, especially Pakistani premier Mian Nawaz Sharif signaled a new beginning in India’s external affairs.
Modi seems to address the issue of Indo-Pakistan relation. Following the searing in ceremony, Modi and Sharif met the next day in New Delhi to feel the each other’s pulse and pressure
The nearly hour long bilateral meeting on 27th May between Prime Ministers of India and Pakistan, Narendra Modi and Nawaz Sharif at Hyderabad House, the residence of Vice President of India Dr. Hamid Ansari, New Delhi ended without any communiqué announced so far.
By all standards, the meeting was a casual, friendly and warm up one to promote ties and they are not expected to make any policy decisions over a cup of high tea. The notes from foreign and military ministries of both countries should have made the meeting very cautious.
Sharif was seen being escorted by External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj following the meeting as Prime Minister Modi was scheduled to have a meeting with Bangladesh Parliament Speaker Dr. Shirin Sharmin Chaudhury.
What have transpired between the two leaders during their meeting was not known. The two leaders are believed to have held consultations on issues of mutual interest related to the two countries. it was expected both would somehow touch upon major issues troubling them for years, notwithstanding the fact that they have no readymade solutions. Terrorism and Kashmir were slated for major attention. Many Pakistani fanatics want joint cricketism exercises between India and Pakistan, no matter if fixed in favor of India.
Since Modi surprised all speculators about ministers and portfolios by enacting a concise ministry with his own choice of people to handle key ministries, it is certain Modi would have departed from the usual meeting styles by avoiding major issues. .
However, Indian media report that Modi, like his predecessors had done before him, had asked Pakistani premier to stop cross border terrorism (a favored Indian diplomatic expression for mutual firings) into Indian soil and sped up Mumbai terror case. Since such has always been the reporting of fanatic Indian media to keep Hindu fanatics in good humors and as such the supposed new but usual Indian bully directed at Islamabad cannot be taken as its face value.
Earlier, before the meeting started, Sharif and Modi shook hands and exchanged pleasantries during their photo opportunity before moving inside for bilateral talks in the presence of officials from both sides. In the morning, Modi met leaders from Afghanistan, Maldives, Sri Lanka, Bhutan, Mauritus and Nepal.
Nawaz Sharif said that cooperation, rather than confrontation, should be the focus of ties between India and Pakistan. Sharif, who was in New Delhi to attend Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s swearing-in on May 26, said at a press conference at the Taj Mansingh, “.. we both were in the beginning of a clear mandate from our respective nations. This provides an opportunity to fulfill the hopes of 1.5 billion people of the two countries who want us to focus on people and welfare. We had talks in warm and cordial atmosphere.” On the content of the talks, Sharif said, “Our common agenda is not possible without peace and security. Consequently, it is important for us to work together. Let us change confrontation into cooperation. My government stands ready and is in the spirit of cooperation.” The Pakistan PM said, “We owe our people to overcome a mistrust and enmity. PM Modi reciprocated my sentiments. He stated it was incumbent on both of us to work together for the common objective – peace and development. Let us carry forward our bilateral agenda.”
Sharif said he had a warm and friendly exchange with President Pranab Mukherjee.
According to Pakistani newspaper Dawn, Nawaz told Modi that the meeting was an auspicious occurrence for both the countries and Pakistan and India both have many traditional and cultural similarities. He is also said to have stressed upon strengthening shared values and customs, saying that poverty and illiteracy should be eliminated from the region.
Sharif also denounced arms race and regretted how the two countries wasted valuable time and resources in the past, said the report. Later, Sharif told a news channel he had an “excellent” meeting with Modi. “I had an excellent meeting. We are positive, look forward to a positive outcome.” “PM underlined our concerns relating to terrorism. PM underlined that Pakistan must abide by its commitment to prevent its territory from being used for terror. PM Modi conveyed to PM Nawaz Sharif that Pakistan must ensure speedy trial in 26/11 Mumbai attack case,” she said.
On the Kashmir issue, she said it was decided that “foreign secretaries [of India and Pakistan] will be in touch to find the best way forward”. She refused to divulge more details, saying many issues were discussed in the meeting including people-to-people contact and border management. She also said Modi had accepted Sharif’s invitation to visit Pakistan. “All SAARC leaders invited the PM to visit. He accepted. The dates have to be worked out,” she said, referring to Modi’s bilateral meetings.
According to Pakistani newspaper Dawn, Nawaz told Modi that the meeting was an auspicious occurrence for both the countries and Pakistan and India have many traditional and cultural similarities. He is also said to have stressed upon strengthening shared values and customs, saying that poverty and illiteracy should be eliminated from the region.
Sharif also denounced the arms race and regretted how the two countries wasted valuable time and resources in the past, said the report. Later, Sharif told a news channel he had an “excellent” meeting with Modi. “We are positive, look forward to a positive outcome.”
Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif , who was in New Delhi to attend Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s swearing-in on May 26, said at a press conference at the Taj Mansingh, “I had pointed out that we both were in the beginning of a clear mandate from our respective nations. This provides an opportunity to fulfill the hopes of 1.5 billion people of the two countries who want us to focus on people and welfare. We had talks in warm and cordial atmosphere.”
The Pakistan PM said that cooperation, rather than confrontation, should be the focus of ties between India and Pakistan. Sharif said, “Our common agenda is not possible without peace and security. Consequently, it is important for us to work together. Let us change confrontation into cooperation. My government stands ready and is in the spirit of cooperation…..We owe our people to overcome a mistrust and enmity. PM Modi reciprocated my sentiments. He stated it was incumbent on both of us to work together for the common objective – peace and development. Let us carry forward our bilateral agenda.”
Sharif said he had a warm and friendly exchange with President Pranab Mukherjee. As a departing note, he he leaves “this historic city with a strong sense that the people of our two countries will work together for peace and cooperation. Two foreign secretaries will be meeting soon.”
Earlier, Indian Foreign Secretary Sujatha Singh told the media that Modi raised the issue of cross-border terrorism and sought a speedy trial in the 26/11 case with Sharif. She also said Modi had accepted the invitation of Sharif to visit Pakistan.
One of the outcomes of the new power equations is freezing of Kashmir issue. The RSS has asked the Modi regime to discuss the Article 370 of the Indian Constitution, which has grouped Jammu and Kashmir as a special and different state. Article 370 of the Constitution gives both special status and hence resources to Jammu Kashmir state. Pro-India politicians who rule JK seek full autonomy the state within Indian Union, while many pro-Pakistan Kashmiris seek freedom to join Pakistan. But those Kashmiris who seek full independence both from India and Pakistan (also China) for a free JK nation are disillusioned.
Modi has abstained from recommending the abolition of Article 370. Instead he has called for debate on the benefits of this article for Jammu and Kashmir’s citizens. Modi also has a reputation of having a hardline position on Pakistan and Muslims. This stems not only from his handling of the 2002 Gujarat riots but also his views on various issues that project him as an inflexible leader.
BJP opposes asymmetrical federalism with any kind of constitutional exception for the state of Jammu and Kashmir. Article 370 of the Indian constitution privileges Jammu and Kashmir as the only unit of India to have a constitution of its own, and a limited application not only of the Indian constitution but also of parliamentary legislation. However, when the party led the NDA government from 1999–2004, it put demands to abolish Article 370 on the back burner and adopted a proactive role in officially recognising the Kashmir dispute and institutionalising the peace process. It is in appreciation of the progress made during the NDA’s time that, despite the ideological position of the BJP, Vajpayee is remembered in Kashmir as one of the most dynamic Indian prime ministers. But when BJP government fell in the 2004 elections, the BJP not only went back to its original position of opposing Article 370 but also disowned the peace process initiated by Vajpayee. Especially after the Mumbai terror attack, the BJP adopted a very offensive approach vis-à-vis Pakistan and Kashmir.
The Congress government pretended to pursue peace course while BJP objected. . It was because of the BJP’s aggressive posturing that Manmohan Singh’s government could not take the peace process beyond the opening of routes for people-to-people movement and trade purposes across the Line of Control.
How Modi would handle the issue is important to comprehend his Hindutva stand after the poll. Whether the Kashmir issue would be resolved with the abolition of article on Kashmir and if so in what way remains to be seen.
One thing common between India and Pakistan is the importance of crony capitalism for them as they promote the corporate lords and help them grow their wealth. Although Modi is not a industrialist himself, Sharif very much is.
Modi may not be Vajpayee but he carries the legacy of Vajpayee that would also become an obligation and responsibility for him as sincere leader of Indian subcontnent.
A stable government under a strong leader may be able to deliver things better on the ground. So what direction will the peace process take under Modi?
Joint cricket exercises cannot guarantee stable bilateral relations. Regimes should take time pass fake cricket seriously. Leave cricket at its extra space.
-DR. ABDUL RUFF COLACHAL
_______________
د. عبد راف
Unfortunately, today there is not even one Muslim nation practicing truly Islamic faith and life.
–BY DR. ABDUL RUFF COLACHAL has been an Educationist, Prolific writer, Commentator on world affairs Expert on Mideast Affairs, Former university Teacher; Editor:INTERNATIONAL OPINION; FOREIGN POLICY ISSUES; Author of books;